BIPV Solar Shingles vs. PV Solar Panels Vs. New Tesla Solar Roof, Plus Solar Energy Cost Estimates

BIPV solar shingles are designed to replace the conventional, bulky solar panels that get bolted onto the roof. The main benefit of BIPV solar shingles and tiles is their integrated installation as part of the overall roof installation process, rather than adding the traditional PV solar panels by drilling the holes into the roof after it has already been installed. Thus, building integrated photovoltaics (BIPV) are an integral part of the roof — essentially they are what comprises the roof over your home — in other words, they are the roof itself! 😉

bipv-apollo-tile-2

BAPV Vs. BIPV Solar Shingles

Today, there is somewhat of a hybrid middle ground known as building applied photovoltaics (BAPV), which refers to solar panels or shingles that are retroactively mixed or integrated within the building. The BAPV solar shingles resemble having a large skylight on the roof, as they are only a portion of the total roof.

BIPV Solar Shingles

New York state manufacturer and installer of BIPV solar systems Suntegra claims that 75 percent of homeowners prefer the BIPV type of system. The upgrades include semi-transparent solar glazing, which also trumps basic skylights and windows. In addition, solar facades for buildings that face the sun are another growing option.

Suntegra solar tiles

With a fully integrated BIPV solar shingles system, you can have a roof comprised entirely of solar shingles. That’s right, you may no longer have to mix it with asphalt! At first, much like tongue and groove hardwood floors, the original solar shingles could only connect with standard asphalt shingles. Dow Chemical has been trying to solve this problem. However, now that Dow Solar is no longer a factor in the solar shingles industry, Elon Musk has burst onto the scene with his recent announcement and demo of his own version of solar shingles.

What’s more, with Tesla’s recently approved acquisition of SolarCity, having a 100% solar shingle or solar tile roof can become a not so distant, albeit expensive possibility for many homeowners looking to replace their aging asphalt roofs.

New solar shingles can resemble traditional roofing materials, such as cedar shake, a multitude of concrete or clay tiles, traditional slates, and polymer. In addition, the new shingles also work free of rack mounts, so the installation and the final product can now be simpler, quicker, and more elegant than before. This is also an improvement for future replacements!

Solar Shingles Vs. Solar Panels

Installation of PV Solar Panels on a Flat Roof

The development of solar roofing shingles and tiles has been in the works since 2005. While many companies have tried to create affordable and cost-effective solar shingles, the industry has struggled to introduce the kind of solar shingles that could compete with the traditional PV solar panels on the merit of affordability and power-generating capacity on a per square foot basis.

Pricing of Solar Shingles and a Note on the Demise of Dow’s PowerHouse Shingles

With Dow Chemical, the average residential cluster would consist of approximately 350 solar panels, with the installation cost of approximately $20,000 to $30,000.

While solar prices can be significant upfront, a well designed solar power system can save homeowners approximately 40 to 60 percent on their electric bill. For the average North Carolina household, this could mean a bill of $120 instead of $300 in July.

Dow Solar is out, Elon Musk and his version of the Tesla Solar Roof are in!

After becoming a dominant player in the solar shingles roofing market, Dow Chemical has closed their solar shingles division in July of 2016. Some of their last products just went out the door in August, making their version of the product obsolete in a little less than five years.

“The demise of the business reflects the difficulty of BIPV within the solar roofing market.” Green Tech Media’s contributor Julian Spector writes, “The Powerhouse Solar System joins a long line of nifty green products that couldn’t find enough customers.” With the king no longer on the throne, there is room for new companies to take their shot at the new technology.

Elon Musk has already demoed his version of Solar Roof followed by the acquisition of SolarCity by Tesla. If Tesla solar shingles roof ever becomes a reality, it will probably launch soon in select markets in California. Given, the past reputation of SolarCity charging an arm and a leg for their conventional, PV solar panel systems, homeowners should be prepared to spend a lot of money — we are estimating that a typical solar tile roof from Tesla (if it’s ever actually made available), coupled with their energy storage battery will tip the scale at anywhere between $60,000 and $90,000 per solar tile roof installed.

Currently available BIPV Solar Shingles Alternatives: Apollo by Certainteed

Certainteed, for example, offers new options for sustainable innovations, and they claim to have done so for over 100 years. Their product, Apollo, has been designed with waterproofing capabilities. These panels create electricity from PV cells, but still manage to filter water like a regular roof, so nothing is required underneath.

Solar shingles and tiles and other types of solar power systems will continue to decrease in price as the technology continues to mature. Federal government is offering 30 percent tax credits to families who invest in a qualified solar power system, where and when applicable. Currently, the majority of states offer solar rebates and incentives.

Getting a Quote for Solar Shingles

The only true way to get an exact price is to call a specialist and ask for a quote. Since Dow has left the game, Certainteed solar shingles will cost about $30,000 to $60,000 for a typical installation (permitting, materials, and labor). There is also a 30 percent federal tax incentive, plus local state incentives.

The cost is largely made up of the quantity of solar shingles required for the job. Your roof’s area with appropriate solar exposure will determine how big a system in kilowatts you can get. When calling for a quote, there are several questions that you should be able to answer.

Certainteed’s product, Apollo, can help homeowners save approximately 40 to 70 percent on their electricity bills with the Apollo Shingle System. Currently, there other products include Apollo II, Apollo Tile II, and Solstice. Each option is slightly different, and its availability may depend upon your location.

To find out more information, the best way to locate installers near you is to visit the CertainTeed website and key in your location. The website allows for potential customers to Find a Pro or Get An Estimate, while also including details on Installation and Warranties.

Install Roof Shingles

$7,500
Average price
Install Metal Roof

$14,500
Average price
Install Flat Roof

$8,225
Average price

See costs in your area Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code

Aiding Musk’s excitement, Rive went on to mention that there are 5 million roofs installed each year and if those new roofs could be made up of solar panels, then “there’s no reason not to go with a power-generating roof.” For those who may need a new roof in the next decade, this could actually be an option.

In an interview with Bloomberg, Musk went on to comment about those homeowners who will soon need a roof. It’s not as if there is a way to avoid the situation, and for those who can afford something that will actually save money, look better, and last longer, it’s somewhat of a no-brainer.

With Dow Chemical having laid the groundwork, it’s not as if Musk and Rive are completely reinventing the wheel. Instead, they are proposing to focus on the one portion of BIPV that benefits residential consumers. Previously too expensive or unfeasible, solar shingles from Tesla could be the missing link.

BIPV vs. Conventional PV Panels

crystalline-solar-panels-installation

Currently, conventional PV solar panels are the most dominant solar-powered system in the US and throughout the world, and there is already a vast, exiting infrastructure for such systems. Over the years, they have been tested to function for an impressive 20 or 30 years, and installers have developed routine systems for the installation of the solar panels.

As traditional PV solar panels’ efficiency continues to improve, their price also continues to fall, which means more financial flexibility for more middle-class families in the future.

For BIPV, on the other hand, the value is added to the home in a number of ways and in the future, solar shingles could replace other external building materials i.e. asphalt shingles, while also lasting longer than conventional asphalt roofs. In addition, the BIPV option would also be much more aesthetically appealing to homeowners and their neighbors.

Thin-Film Solar Laminates for Standing Seam Metal Roofs – Are they still Available?

thin-film-solar-laminates-installation-on-metal-roof

So, yes there is another product that is “sort of” available for standing seam metal roofs. Thin-film photovoltaics are designed for a seamless, peel-and-stick adhesive-style integration with 16 inch wide standing seam metal roofing panels. However, today thin-film solar laminates are not overly wide-spread. In fact, they are no longer being manufactured in the US, because Uni Solar went bankrupt in 2012. However, you can still buy their products on Ebay or Amazon. You would need to get an electrician who would help you get them connected to the inverter, should you decide to buy them.

Note: You can now also get thin-film solar laminates from Globalsolar.com.

One disadvantage of thin-film panels, aside from the current lack of availability, is that they have smaller energy generation density or capacity compared to traditional PV panels. For instance, for a utility-interactive PV system, a typical crystalline module would be 170 to 220 W (STC), have an efficiency between 12% and 17%, and measure approximately 3 by 5 feet.

An amorphous thin-film module might deliver between 60 and 70 W (STC) with an efficiency between 6% and 8%, and measure about 3 by 3 feet, but their elegant installation may make it a worthwhile investment, provided you have a sufficient degree of solar exposure and roof span/area to justify the installation.

Note: Global Solar is claiming the efficiency of 15% on their PowerFLEX®+ Flexible Solar Panels.

Need a Roofer? Get 4 Free Quotes From Local Pros:

Start Here Enter Your Zip Code:

One comment

  1. The only way to get anywhere close to a fair estimate is to actually call up a solar installer in your area, and get a free quote. The price depends vastly on your energy usage, and your location. Two houses can be neighbors, and one can use 20 times as much electricity. Solar hot water costs $4-6k, after which you may get some rebates or credits. Solar electricity costs $6k and up, after which you may get rebates or credits. A typical system, if there is such a thing, is several times that size, and it is not unheard of to have a system 20 times that large.

Leave a Reply